Lovely weight and build on the shoe. The finish is solid and the suede deaign is beautiful. Lacing up is a joy; you pull the two ends of the lace and the shoe tightens up. Sounds really basic but the amount of shoes I have bought from other shoe retailers and this doesn't happen, you can end up re adjusting the laces everytime you put on the shoes.
The 4 star rating is due to the shoe sizes avail are for narrow feet - as discovered. I have slightly wider feet so the fit is quite tight on the sides. Having the option for a wider fit - likes Church's shoes - that would be amazing, but equally not a show stopper for me.